Friday, December 30, 2011
False Testimony
Islam
has come with the establishment of justice and prevention of injustice
as one of its most manifest goals. Justice is the purpose for which
Prophet Muhammad
and all other Messengers, may Allaah exalt their mention, were sent.Allaah Says (what means): "We
have already sent Our messengers with clear evidences and Sent down
with them the Scripture and the balance that the people may maintain
[their affairs] in Justice…" [Quran 25:57]
This
justice touches all aspects of human life and includes the rights of
the Creator and the creatures. Allaah Almighty Says (what means): "Indeed, Allaah orders justice and good conduct and giving to relatives ..."[Quran 16:90]
Only
Islam guarantees the means that lead to the actualization of justice
and its consolidation. One of the means of establishing justice is
giving testimony and knowing its importance. Testimony is the criterion
with which we distinguish between truth and falsehood, and true claims
and false ones. Someone said, "Testimony to people's rights is like the
soul to the body, for as Allaah enlivens bodies with souls, He also
enlivens rights with truthful testimony. It is essential in establishing
a sound social life and all that has to do with it.
Shurayh, a prominent Muslim judge
said, "Judgment is a disease while testimony is a cure. So use the cure for the disease."
Giving testimony its due is an obligatory duty. Allaah Says (what means): "…And establish the testimony for [the acceptance of] Allaah…" [Quran 65:2]
Those
who stand firm in their testimonies are among the people of
righteousness and faith. Among the necessities of faith is giving
truthful testimony even if against oneself or a relative. Allaah Says
(what means): "O
you who have believed, be persistently standing firm injustice,
witnesses for Allaah, even if it be against yourselves or parents and
relatives..." [Quran 4:135]
Establishing
testimony includes giving witness in making contracts and giving it in
front of judges. Muslim scholars said, "Whoever is called to be a
witness over a contract or undertaking - and there is no one besides him
qualified to do that - it is compulsory on him to be a witness over the
transaction. If, however, there are other qualified persons to do that,
it becomes a recommended act and collective obligation."
As
regards giving testimony, the scholars said, "Giving testimony is a
collective obligation whereby if it is carried out by a sufficient
number of people, the whole community is absolved of the obligation. But
if no one does it, the whole community is blameworthy. If there are no
other witnesses that would enable justice to be done and there is a fear
that someone's right may be lost, it then becomes the individual
responsibility of the few available witnesses to testify”.Allaah Says
(what means): "…And let not the witnesses refuse when they are called upon..." [Quran 2:282]
Islam
not only enjoins giving testimony, it also forbids concealing it
because concealing evidence is something that is disapproved of
Islamically and detested by nature. Allaah Says (what means): "…And do not conceal testimony, for whoever conceals it-his heart is indeed sinful..."[Quran, 2:283]
Some
scholars said: "Allaah has not threatened (His slaves) on anything as
much as He has threatened them over the concealment of evidence.
Concealing evidence is a great sin. Allaah Says (what means): "…And we will not withhold the testimony of [i.e. ordained by] Allaah. Indeed, we would then be of the sinful."[Quran 5:106]
Ibn Abbaas
said, "Giving false testimony and concealing testimony is one of the major sins."
Since all these facts have been made clear, it then becomes necessary to know that Sharee'ah
(Islamic Law) has surrounded testimony with hedges that will enable it
to serve its purposes and prevent it from deviating towards what negates
its goals. That is why the basic principle in Sharee'ah is that one's testimony must be based on knowledge, clarity and trust. Allaah Says (what means): "…But only those who testify to the truth [can benefit], and they know." [Quran 43:86]
Allaah also Says, while referring to the sayings of Prophet Yoosuf's (Joseph's) brothers, (what means): "…And we did not testify except to what we knew." [Quran 12:81]
The
scholars said, "Generally speaking, when regarding a matter that can be
seen, like murder, stealing, or fornication, only eye-witness accounts
are suitable (acceptable) as testimony, and if the matter is one that
can be heard like marriage and business contracts, divorce, etc.,
acceptable testimony should be based on hearing”.
To
give testimony on a matter wherein one has no knowledge, or to
purposely testify with the opposite of what we know to be the truth is
regarded as a great sin. False testimony is one that is baseless
whatever the reason may be. Ibn Hajar
said, "False information is to describe something in contrary to its actual form."Somescholarssaid, "Falsehood is something that is outwardly adjusted and beautified so that it may be thought to be truth."
Allaah Says (what means): " …And avoid false statement." [Quran 22:30]
At-Tirmithi
and others reported that the Prophet
delivered a sermon one day and said, "O you people! Giving false testimony is equal to ascribing partners to Allaah." He then recited, "So avoid the uncleanliness of idols and avoid false statement." [Quran 22:30]
Al-BukhaariandMuslim
reported that the Prophet
said, “Should I inform you about the greatest of the great sins?" They (the present companions) said, "Yes, O Allaah's Messenger!" He said, "To join others in worship with Allaah and to be undutiful to one's parents.” The Prophet
then sat up after he had been reclining (on a pillow) and said, “And I warn you against giving a lying speech (false statement)." He kept saying that warning, till we (listeners) thought he would not stop”.
Giving
false testimony has many evils for it supports falsehood against truth
and gives backing to injustice and aggression against justice. It also
effaces fairness and equity and poses danger to public safety and
security.
Therefore, we, Muslims, should take to the path of pious believers about whom Allaah Says (what means): "And [they are] those who do not testify to falsehood, and when they pass near ill speech, they pass by with dignity." [Quran 25:72]
Islamic
Law strongly seeks to establish principles of brotherhood and mutual
love in the Muslim society and remove causes of dissension from among
Muslims. That is why it promulgates the policy of authentication and
keeping records of contracts in order to protect people's rights and
valuables and eliminate corruption and contentions. One of the methods
of authentication is testimony. Allaah Says regarding business
transactions (what means): "And take witnesses when you conclude a contract." [Quran 2:282]
He, the Almighty, also Says regarding revocation of contracts: "And bring to witness two just men from among you and establish the testimony for [the acceptance of] Allaah." [Quran 65:2]
Concerning handing over properties and trusts, Allaah Almighty Says (what means): "Then when you release their property to them, bring witnesses upon them. And sufficient is Allaah as Accountant." [Quran, 4:6]
So,
we, as Muslims, have to obey the injunctions of our Lord and adhere to
His way in order to succeed and have prosperity in this world and the
next.
By: Hussain Ash-Shaikh
Forced marriages
May a father force his virgin
daughter who attained puberty to marry? Two well-known opinions in this
regard are reported from Imaam Ahmad
:
1. That he may compel her to. This is also the opinion of Maalik, Ash-Shaafi`ee, and others
.
2- That he may not. This is the opinion of Abu Haneefah
and others, and is the correct one.
People have differed concerning the
reason permitting the compulsion: whether it is virginity, the daughter
being under-aged, or a combination of both. The correct opinion is that
it is due to her being under-aged, whereas no one can compel a grown-up
virgin in marriage. Abu Hurayrah
reported that the Prophet
said: "A
non-virgin woman may not be married without her command, and a virgin
may not be married without her permission; and enough permission for her
is to remain silent (because of her natural shyness)." [Al-Bukhaari, Muslim & Others]
Thus, the Prophet
prohibited forcing a virgin in marriage without her permission, whether by her father or anyone else. Furthermore, `Aa'ishah
related that she once asked the Prophet
: "In the case of a young girl whose parents marry her off, should her permission be sought or not?" He
replied: "Yes, she must give her permission." She then said: "But a virgin would be shy, O Messenger of Allaah!" He
replied: "Her silence is [considered as] her permission." [Al-Bukhaari, Muslim, & Others]
This applies to the father as well
as others. Furthermore, Islam does not give the father the right to use
any of his daughter's wealth without her permission, how then could he
be allowed to decide, without her permission, how her body (which is
more important than her wealth) is to be used, especially when she
disagrees with that and is mature enough to decide for herself?
Also, there
is evidence and consensus in Islam to restrict an underage person’s free
control of his wealth or person. However, to make virginity a reason
for the restriction contradicts that Islamic principle.
As for the difference between the non-virgin and virgin in the Hadeeth (narration) of the Prophet
it is not a distinction between compulsion and non-compulsion; the difference between the two cases is that:
(a) The non-virgin gives her instructions for the marriage whereas the virgin gives permission, and that
(b) The
virgin’s silence counts as permission. The reason for this is that a
virgin would be shy to discuss the matter of marriage, so she is not
proposed to directly; rather, her Wali (legal guardian) is approached,
he takes her permission, and then she gives him the permission, not the
command to marry her.
As for a non-virgin, she would not
have the shyness of a virgin anymore; thus she can discuss the matter of
her marriage. She can be proposed to, and she gives the command to her
Wali to perform the marriage, and he must obey her.
Thus, the Wali is command-executor
in the case of the non-virgin, and is permission-seeker in the case of
the virgin. This is what the words of the Prophet sallallaahu' alayhi wa
sallam indicate.
As for compelling her to marry
against her will, this would contradict Islamic Law. Allaah, the
Exalted, did not permit a Wali to force her to sell or render her
property without her permission. Nor did He permit him to force her to
eat or drink or wear that which she does not wish. How could he (the
Wali) then oblige her to accompany and copulate with a person whose
company she hates - at the time when Allaah has inseminated love and
mercy between the two spouses? If such company happens, despite her
hatred and repulsion, where is the love and mercy?
Source: 'Al-Masaa’il Al-Maardeeniyyah' by: Imaam Ibn Taymiyyah
Islam's position on homosexuality
Homosexuality and lesbianism have been dubbed
'alternative life-styles', 'personal preference', 'natural variation',
etc. In the West today, where homosexuality was once considered an
illness by the Association of Psychiatrists, it has now been removed
from the list and replaced by homophobia (the dislike of homosexuals and
homosexuality). Consequently, Islam and Muslims are considered
intolerant and biased due to their continued opposition. Arguments in
favour of tolerance towards homosexuals are based on the assumption that
homosexual behaviour is biologically based and not merely learned from
society.
1. Early opposition to homosexuality was based
on the argument that such behaviour was unnatural. Sodomy cannot
produce children, which is one of the main natural consequences of
sexual relations. 'Mother Nature' did not make us that way, it was
argued. To counter such arguments, homosexual researchers scoured the
earth until they found supposed homosexual behaviour among the animal
kingdom. They found that the males of some species of exotic fishes off
the coast of Japan
imitated the behaviour of females of the species in order to prevent
other males from impregnating their mates, and some rare butterflies
from islands off the coast of Africa
also had males exhibiting female behaviour during mating season, etc.
However, if the animal kingdom is to be used to justify human behaviour,
there also exists a spider in South America whose female is much larger than the male. When mating is complete, the female eats her mate.
2. During the 1980’s it was claimed that a gland in the base of
the brain which is small in women and large in men was found to be small
among homosexuals. However, this evidence, while seeming
incontrovertible to the layman, was immediately refuted by scientists.
The data was taken from cross-sections of the brains of dead adult
humans whose sexual preference was identified prior to death.
Consequently, the reduced size of that gland among homosexuals could
have been a result of the practice and not its cause. That is, they
could have been born with normal-sized glands which then became small
due to their deviant lifestyle.
3. Recently, genetics has become the most commonly used
foundation for the pro-gay argument. In 1993 Dr. Dean Hamer, a
researcher at the National Cancer Institute, claimed to have discovered
'the first concrete evidence that ‘gay genes’ really do exist.'
Homosexual orientation was supposedly transmitted to males on the X
chromosome from the mother. Hamer’s findings, published in the
prestigious journal 'Science', transformed his colourless career as a
government scientist into a dynamic media personality and he penned his
memoirs. He gave expert testimony to the Colorado Supreme Court that
formed the basis of the victorious decision striking down anti-gay
propositions. However, a replication of his study at the University of Western Ontario
failed to find any linkage whatsoever between the X chromosome and
sexual orientation. It was also found that Hamer’s study lacked a
control group; a fundamental principle of scientific research.
Furthermore, in June 1994, the Chicago Tribune
reported that a junior researcher in Hamer’s laboratory who assisted in
the gene mapping in the homosexuality study, alleged that he selectively
reported his data. She was then summarily dismissed from her
post-doctoral fellowship in Hamer’s lab. But a National Institute of
Health investigation substantiated her claims and gave her another
position in a different lab. Though Dr. Hamer was coy about his own
sexuality in his memoirs, he later admitted in his lectures that he was
gay.
4. It should be noted that Islam, in its final form, did not
introduce anti-gay legislature to the world. The texts of the Torah are
replete with clear condemnations of such practices.
5. The consequence of AIDS is enough to prove that homosexuality
is evil and dangerous to society. The early spread of AIDS was
concentrated among the homosexual community. It later spread to the
heterosexual and the so-called bisexual community through blood
transfusions and intravenous drug usage. Its spread continues on a
rampage among promiscuous heterosexuals.
6. Islam considers homosexuality to be the result of a choice.
It is inconceivable that God made people homosexuals then declared it a
crime and prescribed punishments for it in both this life and the next.
To accept such a proposition is to accept that God is unjust.
Inclinations can exist within humans for a variety of natural and
unnatural acts, from fornication to rape and from necrophilia to
bestiality. These inclinations may come from jinn-suggestions, media
influence, or even from human whisperings or direct contact. Sodomy was
common among the people of Prophet Loot (Lot)
who lived in Sodom, Palestine; after they had rejected his advice to
give up this evil practice, Allaah Almighty crushed and then annihilated
their city. The Quran describes that punishment in the verse which
means: "So when Our
commandment came, We made the highest part [of the city] its lowest and
rained upon them stones of hard clay in succession." [Quran: 11:82]
Human beings are not like robots who only do what
they are programmed to. Humans choose and God holds them responsible for
their choices. Were homosexuality a product of genetic destiny, it
would be unfair for God to criminalise it and punish those who practice
it. Currently, some scientists are even claiming that murder is of
genetic origin. To accept that would mean to excuse murderers and
tolerate murder.
7. Islam instructs parents to separate their children in their
beds by the age of ten in order to avoid sexual experiences which may
result from childhood experimentation. Such experiences may be
reinforced by contacts in schools and through abuse from adults. Also,
the distinctions between male and female are strongly made in Islamic
teachings.
Prophet Muhammad
cursed men who imitate women and women who imitate men. Abu Hurayrah,
may Allah be pleased with him, said: "The Messenger of Allaah
cursed the man who wears women’s clothes and the woman who wears men’s clothes." [Abu Dawood & Ibn Maajah]
By: Dr. Abu Ameenah Bilal Philips
Accusing chaste women of adultery
Allaah Almighty Says in the Noble Quran (what means):
"The
[Unmarried] woman or [unmarried] man found guilty of sexual intercourse—
lash each one of them with a hundred lashes, and do not be taken by
pity for them in the religion [i.e. law] of Allaah, if you should
believe in Allaah and the Last Day. And let a group of the believers
witness their punishment. The fornicator does not marry except a
[female] fornicator or polytheist, and none marries her except a
fornicator or a polytheist, and that [i.e. marriage to such persons] has
been made unlawful to the believers. And those who accuse chaste women
(of adultery) and then do not produce four witnesses — lash them with
eighty lashes and do not accept from them testimony ever after. And
those are the defiantly disobedient. Except for those who repent
thereafter and reform, for indeed Allaah is Forgiving and Merciful." [Quran 24: 2-5]
Islamic law (Sharee'ah) prescribes a very heavy penalty for adultery.
However, Islam does not legislate such a penalty without first putting
in place sufficient legislation that protects people against falling in
sin. It also ensures that the punishment is not enforced except in cases
where there is certainty about the offence and its perpetrators. Islam
is a complete code of living that is not based on punishment. Its basis
is to provide all that promotes a clean and morally pure life. If some
individuals then abandon such a clean and easy life in order to
deliberately submerge themselves into filth, they incur such heavy
penalty.
In the case of adultery, Islam requires four witnesses to testify
that they have seen the offence, or else, a clear and confirmed
confession by the perpetrators.
It may be suggested, then, that the punishment is unreal and
unenforceable, which renders it ineffective as a deterrent. Punishment
is not the basis of the Islamic approach; its basis is prevention,
education and cultivating people’s finer feelings and consciences so
that they refrain from even contemplating this offence.
Imaam Maalik
narrated that a man confessed to fornication in the time of the Messenger of Allaah
. The Messenger of Allaah
called for a whip, and he was brought a broken whip. He
said: "Above this," and he was brought a new whip whose knots had not been cut yet. He
said: "Below this," and he
was brought a whip which had been used and made flexible. The Messenger of Allaah
gave the order and he was flogged. Then he
said:
"O people! Observe the limits of Allaah. Whoever has committed any of
these ugly things (adultery or fornication) should cover them up with
the veil of Allaah. Whoever reveals to us his wrong action, we shall
perform what is in the Book of Allaah against him (i.e. the prescribed
penalty)." [Maalik]
Prescribing a very harsh punishment for adultery is not sufficient,
on its own, to protect the Muslim community and ensure the purity of its
atmosphere. Therefore, a supplementary order is given to isolate the
adulterers from the rest of the Muslim community. It goes further to
remove the air of the offence from the Muslim community, prescribing a
heavy punishment for those who accuse chaste women of adultery without
providing firm evidence in support of their accusation. Allaah Almighty
Says in the Quran (what means):
“And
those who accuse chaste women of adultery and then do not produce four
witnesses — lash them with eighty lashes and do not accept from them
testimony ever after. And those are the defiantly disobedient. Except
for those who repent thereafter and reform, for indeed Allaah is
Forgiving and Merciful".” [Quran 24: 2-5]
Allowing people to accuse chaste women, whether married or not,
without a clear proof means that people could always make up such
accusation, fearing no repercussion. This means that the Muslim
community finds itself with a stained reputation. Every individual is
threatened with false accusation. Every man suspects his wife, and every
wife suspects her husband, and people doubt their legitimacy. In such
an intolerable state of doubt and suspicion, every family is undermined.
Moreover, when such accusations are frequently made, those who steer
themselves away from adultery will begin to think that the crime is
common in society. Thus, people begin to think about adultery in a
different spirit, with its ghastly nature sounding less ghastly as a
result of its frequent mention. Those who would not have contemplated it
at all may begin to think of doing so, feeling that many others are
doing it.
Thus, in order to protect people’s honor and their suffering from
suspicion as a result of uncorroborated accusations, the Quran
prescribes for false accusation a punishment that comes close to that of
adultery. The punishment is flogging with 80 stripes, rejecting their
testimony in any case or situation, and giving them the label of
transgressors. The first part of the punishment is physical, while the
second is moral. It is sufficient that the accuser is deprived of the
right to testify, and considered deceitful. The third part of the
punishment is a religious one. The one guilty of false accusation is
following a line that deviates from that of faith. The only way to
protect himself from such punishments is that the accuser should provide
four witnesses who have seen the offence being committed, or three
alongside him if he himself has seen it.
It is agreed upon by Muslim scholars that for adultery (or
fornication) case to be authentically proven, four witnesses must
simultaneously see, by their own eyes, the man's sexual organ inserted
in the woman's sexual organ. Only when these four witnesses give such
testimony is the accusation proved and the punishment of adultery (or
fornication) is enforced on the perpetrators.
Such restrictions are set forth by Sharee'ah in order to limit to the
least minimum the possibility of falsely accusing chaste women of
adultery (or fornication), which leads to social and psychological
troubles for the accused women. Even when such a sin –adultery (or
fornication) - is committed, such restrictions laid by Sharee'ah will
guarantee the suppression of the crime and prevents its spread among the
people, which contaminates the morally pure Muslim community.
It is agreed upon by Muslim scholars that for adultery (or fornication) case to be authentically proven, four witnesses must simultaneously see, by their own eyes, the man's sexual organ inserted in the woman's sexual organ. Only when these four witnesses give such testimony is the accusation proved and the punishment of adultery (or fornication) is enforced on the perpetrators.
Such restrictions are set forth by Sharee'ah in order to limit to the least minimum the possibility of falsely accusing chaste women of adultery (or fornication), which leads to social and psychological troubles for the accused women. Even when such a sin –adultery (or fornication) - is committed, such restrictions laid by Sharee'ah will guarantee the suppression of the crime and prevents its spread among the people, which contaminates the morally pure Muslim community.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




